* NOW WITH STAR RATINGS (ala Wrestling Observer Newsletter PPV reports) *
HOW I RATE THE COMICS VIA THE ALAN MOORE SCALE
***** Watchmen, Miracleman, V For
Vendetta
**** From Hell, Supreme, Swamp Thing, Fashion Beast,
League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen (first two series)
*** Axel Pressbutton, Tom
Strong
** Promethea
* LoEG: Century: 1969
DUD (or
lower) any of his non-comics stuff
1.-24. Essential Godzilla #2 (Marvel, 2006) ***
- originally published in Godzilla #1-24 (Marvel, 1977-79)
Writer: Doug Moench/Artists: Herb Trimpe & friends
A podcast on this book is coming soon.
Toho Productions’ gave Marvel a two-year run with Godzilla
and it was bizarre.
Godzilla emerges from an iceberg in Alaska and goes on a
rampage. He’s evil for the first three issues, attacking Seattle and San
Francisco. But that quickly grows boring, so they make him a sorta good guy
(like the Hulk).
Even though he kills thousands of people (even in Marvel’s
PG world, there’s no way he couldn’t have wiped out oodles of folk in those
cities he destroyed.
Dr Takiguchi, his niece Tamara and annoying grandson Rob
create a giant Shogun Warrior-style robot to fight Godzilla.
After that, Godzilla fights alien monsters, battles
rustlers, gets shrunk and fights New York sewer rats, then is sent back in time
to fight dinosaurs.
Along the way, Godzilla tangles with SHIELD, The Champions,
The FF, The Avengers and Devil Dinosaur. It’s weirdly stupid, kinda boring and
ends with Godzilla getting written out of Marvel continuity.
At least it means there’s no more Rob, because he’s truly
annoying.
25. Vreckless Vrestlers #0 (Vreckless Comics, 2014) **3/4
Writer/artist: Lucasz Kowalczuk
It's in French! Luckily, there's not much dialogue.
26. All-Star Section Eight #4 (DC, 2015) ****
25. Vreckless Vrestlers #0 (Vreckless Comics, 2014) **3/4
Writer/artist: Lucasz Kowalczuk
It's in French! Luckily, there's not much dialogue.
26. All-Star Section Eight #4 (DC, 2015) ****
Writer: Garth Ennis/Artist: John McCrea
Garth Ennis really, really, REALLY hates Wonder Woman.
27. Starve #4 (Image, 2015) *****
Writer: Brian Wood/Artist ;Danijel Zezelj
28. We Stand On Guard #3 (Image, 2015) ****¼
Writer: Brian K. Vaughan/Artist: Steve Skroce
29. Minimum Wage: So Many Bad Decisions #5
(Image, 2015) *****
Writer/artist: Bob Fingerman
30. Jupiter’s Circle #6 (Image, 2015) ****
Writer: Mark Millar/Artists: Wilfredo Torres (interior);
Frank Quitely (cover)
31. Groot #4 (Marvel, 2015) ***½
Writer: Jeff Loveness/Artists: Brian Kesinger
(interiors)/Declan Shalvey & Jordie Bellaire (covers)
32. Deadly Class #16 (Image, 2015) ****
Writer: Rick Remender/Artist: Wes Craig
33.-38. JSA Liberty
Files: The Whistling Skull #1-6 (DC, 2013) ***½
Writer: B. Clay Moore/Artist: Tony Harris
39. Shogun Warriors #2 (Marvel, 1978) **
Writer: Doug Moench/Artists: Herb Trimpe & Dan Green
40.-44. The Return Of Valkyrie (Eclipse, 1989)
**½
- originally published in Airboy #1-5 (Eclipse, 1989)
Writers: Timothy Truman & Chuck Dixon/Artists: Timothy
Truman, Tom Yeates, Stan Woch & Will Blyberg (interiors); Timothy Truman,
Stan Woch & Dave Stevens (original covers); Jim Steranko (collection cover)
45. The Air
Fighters Meet Sgt. Strike Special #1 (Eclipse, 1988) **
Story: Chuck Dixon/Artist: Tom Lyle
46. Target: Airboy #1 (Eclipse, 1988) *
Writer: Don Chin & Chuck Dixon/Artists: Sam Kieth, Sam
De La Rosa & Russ Sever
47. Airboy And Mr Monster #1 (Eclipse, 1987)
***
Writer: Michael T. Gilbert/Artists: Michael T. Gilbert &
Mark Pacella
48. Airboy Meets the Prowler (Eclipse, 1987)
*
Writer: Timothy Truman & Chuck Dixon (with Michael H.
Price)/Artists: John K. Snyder III & Graham Nolan
49. Heavy Metal #276 (Heavy Metal Media,
2015) **
Writers/Artists: various
I haven’t bought a copy of Heavy Metal for some years, but I had to get this ish ’cos of the
Jack Kirby article featuring newly recoloured film concept artwork from the
late 70s that the King did for Lord Of
Light. The art in the feature is great, but the article is kinda meh. Other
than that, it’s your usual HM shit:
Enki Bilal, some other obscure and arty Euro-wankers plus reprints of Paul
Kirchner’s The Bus (arguably the best
thing in the issue). I can seriously see why the publishers have hired Grant
Morrison to edit this rag in 2016 – it really needs a good shake-up to reclaim
its late 70s/early 80s greatness.
50. Avatar Graphic Novel Sampler 2003
(Avatar, 2003) **
Writers/artists: various
51. Silver Surfer #14 (Marvel, 2015) ***½
Writer: Dan Slott/Artist: Michael Allred
52. Bitch Planet #5 (Image, 2015) ****
Writer: Kelly Sue DeConnick /Artist: Valentine De Landro
53.-58. Saga Vol. 5 (Image, 2015) *****
Writer: Brian K. Vaughan/Artist: Fiona Staples
59. Action Comics #900 (DC, 2011) ***¾
Writers/Artists: various
60. Judge Dredd: Mega-City Two #1 (IDW,
2014) ***
Writer: Douglas Wolk/Artist: Ulises Farinas
61. Captain Canuck #2 (Comely Comix, 1975)
DUD
Writers/Artists: various
Godawful Canadian-made comic strip, badly written and draw.
Also, there’s a bullshit article in it claiming that movies and TV influence
children’s behaviour. It’s really fucking horrible (and badly researched). Fuck
this comic.
62. New MGMT #1/Mind MGMT #36 (Dark Horse, 2015) *****
Writer/Artist: Matt Kindt
Very sad to see this great series come to an end. Also, this
ends my hard-copy single issue relationship with Dark Horse. Mind MGMT was the only comic I still
bought from this company (the rest I get free from the company as digital
copies).
63. Foodang #1 (Entity Comics, 1996) ½*
Writer: Michael Duggan/Artists: Michael Duggan & Mike
Sagara
A clown as a superhero living with a family of cannibal
killers? Not good.
64. The Black Hood #2 (Red Circle, 1983) **
[Black Hood first story] Writer: Gary Cohn/Artist: Pat
Boyette
[Black Hood second story] Writer: John Carbonaro & Rich
Margopoulos/Artist: Dan Spiegle
[The Fox] Writer/Artist: Alex Toth
Cover Artist: Alex Toth
Toth is great – the rest is typical mediocre Red Circle
fare.
65. Tales Of Dread Album (G.T. Ltd, c. Early
1960s) *
Writers/Artists: various
Cheap UK reprint of low-grade sci-fi, horror and western
yarns from the USA. The only artist of note that I recognised was Steve Ditko.
Some of the stories appear to be abbreviated to fit to space. Not that it
matters – they’re all very clichéd and lame.
66. Space War #30 (Charlton, 1978) *
Writers/Artists: various
Below-average sci-fi yarns. The only thing that’s notable is
that one tale, The Anywhere Machine!,
has layouts by Wally Wood, but he must have done just the minimum of pencils,
because the art itself is by Tom Sutton and it’s sub-par. Other than that, this
comic is completely forgettable.
67. Archer & Armstrong #0 (Valiant,
1992) **
Writers: Bob Layton & Jim Shooter/Artists: Barry
Windsor-Smith & Ralph Reese
68. Australian MAD #467 (Next Media, 2011)
***
Writers/Artists: the usual gang of idiots
I popped when I read “How Does Captain America Stack Up
Against Other Legendary Captains?” and saw Captain Lou Albano...and he rated
better than the other Cap!
69. Supermen Of America #1 (DC, 1999) **
Writer: Stuart Immonen/Artists: various
70. Harvey Kurtzman’s New Two-Fisted Tales
(Dark Horse, 1994) ***½
Writers: various/Artists: various (interiors); Harvey
Kurtzman & William Stout (cover)
71.-73. Scatterbrain #1-3 (Dark Horse, 1998) ***
Writers/artists: various
74. Monster Wrestlers In My Pocket Annual 1996 (Egmont Publishing, 1996) *
Writer; Mike Butcher/Artists: Tim Perkins, Leo Brown, Simon
Clegg and John Moore
Remember Monsters In
My Pocket from the early 90s? Those creepy lil’ toys were kinda cool (even
for a guy in his late 20s), so I should have loved Wrestlers In My Pocket when I discovered them while holidaying in
the UK in 1995. They were like an English version of Kinnikuman. But somehow they were kinda lame and didn’t last long.
This annual was the one attempt I found to cash in on the fad. It’s pretty bad,
even by wrestling comics’ low standards.
75. In The Days Of The Mob #1 (DC/Hampshire,
1971) ***½
Writer: Jack Kirby/Artists: Jack Kirby & Vince Colletta.
Plus toons by Sergio Aragones
Picked up this holy grail of failed DC comics on special at
Comic Kingdom in Sydney a few months back. One of Jack’s better efforts, but
the 1920s gangster yarns were a probably bit too obscure for hip 70s kids to
appreciate. Pity.
76. Cracked Magazine #171 (Major Magazines,
1980) *
Writers/artists: various
77. Life With Archie #9 (Archie, 2011) *
Writers/artists: various
I only bought this mag because it had articles about Lady
Gaga on it. Pretty sad, eh?
78. Anthro #6 (DC, 1969) **
Writer: Howie Post/Artists: Howie Post & Wally Wood
Nice inks by Wally, but the story is pedestrian.
79. Vanguard Illustrated #2 (PC, 1984) *
Writers/artists: various
Only worthwhile for the Dave Stevens cheesecake cover.
80. Twisted Tales #5 (PC, 1983) *½
Writer: Bruce Jones/Artists: various (interior), Richard
Corben (cover)
Great stuff from Corben, as usual.





No comments:
Post a Comment